Caster Semenya - racism? - Instablogs
Caster Semenya - racism?
Lucy Donald , Giyani: Aug 22 2009
Made Popular Aug 24 2009
South Africa :

Caster Semenya - racism?

The issue surrounding Caster Semenya’s gender has been taken to another level by the Young Communist League of South Africa, stating she has become a victim of racism.

While I sympathize with Semenya, and the trauma that has been incurred by suggesting she is not female, the issue is not one of racism. My sister stated she had heard she was a hermaphrodite, a carrier of both sexual reproductive organs, making her sexuality difficult to determine.

Recently, her mother has shown her birth certificate to indicate she is female, but if she is a hermaphrodite, the gender is determined at birth by the parents - you get to choose, and then raise your child in that gender. If she holds both gender genes, then whichever is in the majority should determine her gender.

Of course, she may actually be female and all this is not necessary. She must feel an outcast in society, and all because she wanted to compete for her country in a sport she clearly loves. She should be commended for that, just like all athletes, regardless of gender. Her ability to perform at such a level, whether she is a man or a woman, shows her ability as a sportsperson. I know I will never, ever be able to perform at such a level.

What is now disappointing is the reaction to her gender as racist. People need to realise what racism is. She is not being targeted because she is South African, because she is not white or because she is black. The matter is not one of race, but of gender. People are far too quick to use colour as a means of argument, or as a means of defense. In a country where racism is still rife, in a variety of ways and in a variety of people, to suggest such an issue is one of racism is like lighting a bonfire - it could blow up into a huge international issue.

The reality is, her performance has greatly increased recently, and her GENDER is being questioned. While I appreciate this must be traumatic for her, we must not over-react. The issue is partly resolved as her birth certificate identifies her sex. Leave her be, let her compete for her country and if there is doubt, realise it is not a race issue, but to determine her suitability competing against other females.

Learn not to judge, but to love and celebrate someone’s victories and successes... don’t bring someone down when they succeed.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Lucy Donald
Giyani, South Africa
And the comment is made in the same week when the court case was postponed against the South Africans who had made the ’racist’ video. The video contained footage of ’white’ South Africans feeding ’Black’ South Africans urine-soaked foods as an experiment.
THIS is racist and clearly an attack in the meanest way... but the Government deems it acceptable to not deal with this incident, and blow Semenya’s ordeal out of proportion!
Mmm... the Government needs to re-think.
1 Stars
Pawarin
Brisbane, Australia
This is an appalling and humiliating situation for the poor girl that should never have happened.
1 Stars
Kalpna
Ottawa, Canada
This is so embarrassing for her regardless. If she is a girl or if she didn't know she used to be guy, really horrific for this person.
1 Stars
Nick
Brisbane, Australia
if she looked the way this dude looks.
yeah, they will. its not a race thing, and quit trying to make it look like it is..
1 Stars
Nicholas
Birmingham, United Kingdom
Well, a woman who looks like a man, talks like a man, has the physical shape of a man wins over all the other women? masculine superiority? However she does remind me of Serena and Venus williams somewhat.
1 Stars
Lucy Donald
Giyani, South Africa
Today, it was determined that Semenya has testosterone levels three times higher than a female... the question now remains, should she compete as a male or a female?
1 Stars
Sterling Hou
Naga City, United States
Stop from judging her when you are just looking at her physical appearance. She’s not doing anything bad against us.Perhaps after the Caster Semenya magazine cover the debate should be over. The Caster Semenya magazine cover certainly has let people see her with a makeover and she appears very feminine. However, according to rumor, a leak of the gender test results the South African sprinter had to undertake revealed that she is a hermaphrodite. True hermaphroditism is when an organism has both male and female reproductive features and organs. In humans, there are numerous ways in which some form of sexual diffusion can occur, some relatively benign, and some crippling. Either way, the Caster Semenya magazine cover might lead some to think that online payday loans towards finding her gender might be ill spent. Why keep on ruining someones life when you can’t manage your own?.
1 Stars
Lucy Donald
Giyani, South Africa
She has been ’attacked’ because she is different, but the question is not one of physical appearance, nor racism. The only question that should be asked, is whether she has an unfair advantage against peers of the same gender. Most of us care little for how she looks - a lot of female athletes look masculine because of the muscle groups they work.
Add your Comment